| Name | Years |
|---|---|
| Richard James | 1632 – 1637 |
| Hampton (official position unknown) | 1634 – 1635 |
| William Cotton | 1635 – 1636 |
| Vacant or Ministers Unknown | 1636 – 1721 |
| Thomas Phillips | 1721 – 1738 |
| Henry Hunter | 1739 – 1740 |
| George Moore | 1740 – 1741 |
| John Bradford | 1742 – 1744 |
| Samuel Hunter | 1744 – 1746 |
| Hamilton Bell | 1748 – 1748 |
| John Thornton | 1748 – 1754 |
| Edward Dingle | 1754 – 1758 |
| Patric Hamilton (lay reader) | 1758 – 1766 |
| Samuel Howard | 1766 – 1768 |
| John Patterson | 1768 – 1769 |
| Matthias Harris | 1769 – 1773 |
| John Andrews | 1773 – 1773 |
| Thomas Lendrum | 1773 – 1775 |
| William Hanna | 1775 – 1778 |
| Vacant | 1778 – 1806 |
| John Hooker Reynolds | 1806 – 1809 |
| Vacant | 1809 – 1826 |
| Matthias Harris | 1826 – 1830 |
| Vacant | 1830 – 1839 |
| Norris Marshall Jones | 1839 – 1844 |
| William Walsh | 1844 – 1846 |
| Cyrus Waters | 1846 – 1846 |
| John Augustine Thompson | 1847 – 1865 |
| James Moore | 1865 – 1866 |
| Joseph Newton Wattson | 1869 – 1872 |
| P.D. Thompson | 1874 – 1892 |
| Charles S. Spencer | 1893 – 1906 |
| William N. Weir | 1907 – 1912 |
| Mathews R. Bowie | 1912 – 1914 |
| W. H. Darbie | 1915 – 1917 |
| Hunter Davidson | 1917 – 1921 |
| Walter C. Eastburn | 1923 – 1926 |
| Alward Chamberlin | 1927 – 1932 |
| Matthews S. Higgins | 1933 – 1940 |
| Lay Readers | 1940 – 1947 |
| Francis K. McNaul, Jr. | 1947 – 1949 |
| Vernon Lane | 1950 – 1952 |
| James D. Cummins (supply) | 1952 – 1953 |
| Hugh V. Clary | 1953 – 1960 |
| Robert Clarke | 1960 – 1972 |
| Robert A. Gourlay | 1972 – 1988 |
| James J. “Bud” Shand | 1989 – 2003 |
| David Robert Green | 2004 – 2013 |
| Mark S. Delcuze |
2013 – 2023 |
| Frank B. Crumbaugh, III |
2023 – |
Christ Church Parish Kent Island
